wanna talk POA? [Archive] - AmityMama.com

View Full Version : wanna talk POA?


harvestgirl
06-05-2004, 08:57 AM
what did you think?

i loved it... BUT - yea, just a small one ;) i was bummed that several explanations were left out. (mooney, wormtail, padfoot, & prongs) does hary even know his dad was one of the marauders, an animagi/ stag & his patronus? ~ quidditch was WAY short...where was oliver wood?
no pigwidgeon for ron...*sigh*

i guess if you read the books, you may be a tad dissapointed, but if you never did & just saw the film, you'd like it...but be a bitperplexed i suppose.

i loved alfonso cuaron's direction & was even happily accepting of the new Hogwart's layout - hagrid'shut was much further away, as was the whomping willow.

ron was hilarious, but was in the background a bit much i thought ~ i really liked the time-turner scene as well.

i wish the shreiking shack scene was longer.

overall, i think it was really great BUT bummed that the above were left out.