View Full Version : vegitarian or not?
MofCandA
03-17-2004, 12:43 PM
Do you consider someone who eats no meat other than fish/seafood a vegitarian?
I have just never thought of them as smart animals, therefore never worried about them being in pain. Someone told me that a fish's nervous system is different than ours and it doesn't hurt them to get a hook in the mouth. ??????? Is that true? :confused:
Is fish considered meat?
There are a lot of conflicting opinions about this. Some people don't even consider poultry meat! :rolleyes: Some people say if it's not red meat, it's not technically meat.
I think if it's animal flesh, it's meat.
I just have little sympathy for seafood.
Is a fish eater a vegitarian?
Sarahd
03-17-2004, 01:36 PM
No, by definition vegetarians eat NO animal flesh of anykind...any animal product that results in the death or harm of an animal. Fish are animals regardless of the sympathy level you have for them. Vegetarians base their diet on grains, legumes(beans), nuts and seeds, fruits and vegetables.
Lacto-Ovo vegetarians also consume dairy and egg products, but no animal flesh of any kind.
Lacto vegatarians consume dairy products but no eggs or animal flesh.
Vegans are the strictest being that they not only DO NOT consuming animal products they also DO NOT use in any manner ANY animal based product of any kind...including but not limited to leather, silk, honey, white sugar(which is processed using bones of an animal).
Meat by definition is the flesh of animals that is used as food. This is typically associated with cattle, hogs and other four footed creatures, but not limited to. BUT this would never by default leave chicken and fish as a vegetable...which it would have to be called in order to be consumed by a vegetarian. So your assumption that all animal flesh is meat is correct and this includes fish.
SO, no, a fish eater is in no way shape or form by any PROPER definition a vegetarian.
My definitions of vegetarian and meat I got directly out of my dictionary.
I hope this helps answer your questions:).
Selissa
03-18-2004, 01:08 AM
Well said Sarah..only wanted to add that fish do in fact feel pain. They have nerves and pain receptors. and even if they didn't fishing would not be what i would consider humane by any stretch of the imagination....but I'm also a vegan so that puts me in the lot of folks who happen to be especially sensitive to such things. :)
sweetpeasma
03-18-2004, 08:23 AM
Sarah did say it nicely.
I love it when I tell people I'm a vegetarian and they say well we have fish or chicken :rolleyes:
MofCandA
03-29-2004, 03:07 AM
Thank you guys for the information:)
vBulletin® v3.6.5, Copyright ©2000-2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by
vBSEO 3.0.0 RC8